On Trial18 Nov 20265 MIN

I tried three ice creams on the Ninja Creami, and the winner took me by surprise

The viral ice cream maker is for the planners, the protein-maxxers, and the Willy Wonkas

ninja creami the nod review

When I agreed to test the Ninja Creami, I thought I knew how it worked. I had seen influencer videos, recipes, and gushing reviews, but like most students from the school of Instagram, I soon discovered there was more to it.

So, for the uninitiated ice cream enthusiasts, let me clear your first misconception (which was mine too): the Ninja Creami does not—I repeat, does not—freeze your ice cream for you. First, you make a base mixture of the flavour you want—it can be something as simple as vanilla or as complex as protein-toasted butter pecan gelato if you’re so inclined. You then pour it into the Creami’s plastic pint attachment and freeze it for 24 hours. Then, a blade descends into your base and churns it to the consistency you want. I got to pick from ice cream, gelato, light ice cream (a longer cycle designed for low-fat, low-sugar or high-protein recipes), sorbet, milkshake, or smoothie—all the options available in a standard Ninja Creami 7-in-1 ice cream maker. It does its thing for roughly four (loud) minutes, and, voila, you have a frozen treat.

Artboard 4.jpg

No matter how simple your base is, it’s gotta be frozen for the machine to churn it into ice cream, so pre-planning is really the key here. The actual making of the ice cream is the easier bit. The machine comes with two dishwasher-safe pint jars and occupies about one square foot of space on your countertop.

For the purpose of this review, I tried three flavours—a regular coffee ice cream made with full-fat milk and sugar, a Greek-yoghurt-based peanut butter and blueberry jam light ice cream, and a cookies-and-cream vanilla-protein-based ice cream.

No-fuss coffee ice cream

We’re a big coffee household—our gadget corner comprises three coffee-related appliances—two grinders (don’t ask why) and one espresso machine—and now a Ninja Creami. So, it was fitting that our first ice cream should be coffee. My husband pulled a shot of espresso from his fancy machine—though you can substitute it with instant coffee—and I added regular full-fat milk, sugar, a dash of vanilla extract to fancify it, and chucked it in the freezer. What I love most about the Creami is complete lack of mess. You could make and eat a pint of ice cream from beginning to end having only soiled a couple of spoons and the Ninja plastic pint attachment. After a 24-hour wait, the pint was ready to use. We churned it (twice), and 10 minutes later it was ready to eat. This first attempt was more icy than creamy, especially when we tried it a day later, but after chatting with a friend who owns the machine I discovered that xanthan gum was the solution for a creamier result.

Artboard 7.jpg
This first attempt was more icy than creamy, especially when we tried it a day later, but was made with delicious Ethopian coffee

Learning 1: Purchase some xanthan gum powder for extra creaminess.

Learning 2: Make your base just slightly sweeter than you like it, because the science of ice cream making means it will taste just perfect after churning.

Insta-famous peanut butter and blueberry jam light ice cream

A craving courtesy this recipe by @lungiisalwaysbaking that I watch on repeat, this was the most experimental ice cream of the lot. I also wanted it to be low-key healthy, so I used Epigamia Greek yoghurt as my base instead of whole milk and substituted sugar for a dash of honey. Feel free to play around with the quantities and adjust according to your taste. This batch had a much softer texture than the coffee one, but it melted rather quickly. After churning it on the ‘light ice cream’ setting, I used the mix-in feature, which basically gently folds in ingredients post-churning, to add a swirl of peanut butter and blueberry preserve (it preserved the entire berry when mixing in). The fun part is the toppings, so go crazy like I did and add some buttered toast chunks for a real savoury-sweet treat.

IMG_9271 (1).JPG
The mix-in feature gently folds in ingredients post-churning, so I added a swirl of peanut butter and blueberry preserve

Learning 3: Buy some extra pint attachments so you can freeze multiple flavours at a time. This way you'll have something to dig into even while you're waiting the required 24 hours for your newest concoction to get ready. 

Protein-maxxing with cookies-and-cream ice cream

This was the recipe my algo most often fed me—a simple vanilla protein ice cream with cookie mix-in—Oreos seem to be the preference of YouTubers with these protein-maxxing recipes. I used one sachet of Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% whey vanilla-ice-cream-flavoured protein powder, aka whatever was available on Blinkit at the time. First, I shook it in a protein shaker with the recommended amount of Amul skimmed milk to get rid of lumps. And that was it. It took more time to find a spot for it in my freezer than it took to prepare the mixture. The result took me by surprise—it was actually the most ice cream-y texture of the lot and the easiest to put together. Plus, that protein aftertaste we all love to complain about so much was gone, thanks to the dark chocolate cookies we crumbled in.

Vanilla protein ice cream ninja creami
After adding dark chocolate cookies to the ice cream that typical protein aftertaste was gone, 

Learning 4: Leave ice cream you made the previous day out for a couple of minutes before diving in. Since it is free of preservatives and stabilisers, it doesn’t have that same creaminess of say a Baskin Robbins straight out of the freezer, but a few minutes in Mumbai’s heat does the trick.

Learning 5: The most important one is—pre-plan the flavours you want!

TL;DR, making ice cream in the Ninja Creami is quite an easy process, and for those who Swiggy an ice cream every couple of days, it’s a worthwhile investment. Unlike cheaper traditional ice cream makers, here you can make individual servings, concoct some truly whacky flavours, and create low-cal versions of your favourite dessert. Plus, it’s a great wedding/birthday gift. And if the giftee is the person you live with, it’s quite the mutually beneficial arrangement.

The Ninja Creami 7-in-1 ice cream maker is available on sharkninja.in for ₹29,999

The Nod Newsletter

We're making your inbox interesting. Enter your email to get our best reads and exclusive insights from our editors delivered directly to you.